DevTracker Highlights For The Week of April 28, 2011

This week's DevTracker Highlights covers everything from skill trees to keyboards. Lead Systems Designer Damion Schubert dips behind the scenes and explains a normal day for him at the BioWare Austin studio. Principal Lead Combat Designer Georg Zoeller discusses dual specs and their place in Star Wars: The Old Republic. Associate Lead Designer Emmanuel Lusinchi answers questions from the French community about item colorization, dark-side healing, and the fate of the Sith soldier class. All of this and more after the break.
Georg Zoeller confirms the absence of a dual-spec system at release.

Georg Zoeller
Seems obvious that he avoided the question, probably because they won't have dual spec at release.

I think the translation makes it sound like I'm avoiding something there, which isn't the case.

First, we fully understand why dual spec is a popular topic.

Currently, we do not see the need to allow for dual spec at release. It's something that we'll definitely monitor over time, but we do think there is enough flexibility in the class system to keep people occupied well past launch.


Georg Zoeller clears up any confusion about changing skill trees within an Advanced Class and the ability to have two different specs simultaneously.

Georg Zoeller
What it doesn't say is "you can longer pay to reset your tree points and re-do them",which being able to was confirmed a long time ago.

Correct. The ability to respec your skill point distribution is still in the game.

Summary, since this is a confusing topic:

You can change your skill point distribution by paying credits at a vendor on your capital world. That has not changed.

You may or may not be able to change your Advanced Class, we haven't decided on this one yet. If you can, the cost would be significant. That has not changed.

There is currently no plan to add dual spec (the ability to swap almost instantly between two skill point configurations) for launch. At this point, it seems not necessary for us, but we're not opposed to add it at a later point / patch should we feel that the game would benefit from it.

Hope that helps.


Damion Schubert takes us on a verbal tour of the BioWare Austin studio and shares what a day in the life of a BioWare developer is like.

Damion Schubert
So I was wondering, at this stage in development, what's a typical day in the life at Bioware Studios?

The answer to this question is going to vary wildly and dramatically based on who you ask, so I'll answer only for me - keep in mind that my role and position is pretty unique in the team, as I both manage a team of systems designers who do itemization, maps, crew skills and other features, as well as act as a primary liaison from design to several programming teams (yes, that's plural).

So for me, my day is usually a combination of:

- Meetings, and lots of them. Some days, even my lunches are meetings. A project this size takes a lot of communication to keep things rolling smoothly.

- Playtesting

- Triaging issues and design changes

- Managing my team (who are, thankfully, excellent, and take little handholding).

- Writing an occasional design document for a feature or tweak that slipped through the cracks, or needs redesign based on stats and feedback.

When I can sneak in a moment, I try to pop onto the boards and answer a question or two. As you might imagine, though, that time is more limited than I would like.

Is this stage of development stressful or fun?

Can't it be both? I'm currently playing a build very nearly nightly, and it's amazing to see it all coming together so nicely. That being said, it's also incredibly frustrating because we're all perfectionists, and we are constantly pushing to take it to the next level.

Is everyone putting in long hours? More than 1 shift? Get weekends off?

That'll depend on the week and the team - especially if an important imminent build is coming. That being said, even when we take the weekend 'off', we're playing the game a lot - a couple members of my team and I spent Saturday playtesting the group content on Alderaan, which was great fun, but also resulted in several pages of notes for me to fix this week at work.

One of the things that's probably not incredibly obvious to people outside the building is that this project is so big, and has so much content to do, that you can constantly be surprised by work other groups is doing. Usually, this is a good thing. =)

What do you guys do at the office to blow off steam and have fun?

On a team this size, there are a lot of different subcultures that do their own thing. We have a fitness group who prefers to go running instead of take lunch. We have a large weekly poker game, and more than one D&D campaign floating around. We have a large subculture of Magic the Gathering players who I keep intending to go lose to. I tend to hang out with the people who like board games. League of Legends is popular, and you can naturally find players of almost any major MMO you can think of, if you try.

Also, sarcasm. In general, we use sarcasm the way a French chef uses butter - liberally and on everything.

How do you think the intensity of the next few months will affect your work or personal lives?

This late stage a project is always hard, and frequently involves long hours. Fortunately, most of us with spouses are patient and understanding about our career and our passion. In many respects, though, its easier to put the extra oomph on the project now than it was, say, three years ago. Back then, the project was, you know, largely non-existent, amorphous, theoretical. We were still trying to have the fun.

Now we can see what we're building, and what needs to be fixed, tweaked and changed. The game is tangible, and fun. There are issues and flaws, no doubt, and still enormous challenges to take on before this thing gets into your hands. But for the most part, the sense is one of finally seeing everything I've been working on for years finally come to fruition, and as you imagine, its extremely gratifying to watch it happen.

Are you guys living on frozen burritos?

Bioware treats us very well, thank you. Our founders, Ray and Greg, are very proud of the fact that the studio they founded in Edmonton has won numerous 'best places to work' awards for Canada, and they've done their best to import that culture down to Austin where we work.

As for EA - they've largely left things alone, and in general they're very eager for this team and this project to do well.

Is the Bioware janitor really as talented as people say?

Which one? We have a whole cleaning crew. Sadly, most of my interaction with them is 'is that the sound of vacuuming? Is it really that late?'


Emmanuel Lusinchi recounts BioWare's experiment in item colorization, and talks about the evolution of the item binding system in the game. The post is roughly translated below.

Emmanuel Lusinchi
About the quality of the objects we have so far shown the following: Low quality (gray), standard (bronze, a sort of dull orange), premium (green), prototype (blue) and artifact (purple).

Here's a little info: Initially we used a schematic of metallic colors (bronze - silver - gold - platinum) because everyone is familiar with the values of these metals. It was a good theory, but in practice it ended with a variation of gray and yellow, one that did not really so great! After many trials and some errors, we ended up using more or less like the standard MMO players are already familiar with it.

About linked objects, we showed "Bind on Equip" and "Bind on Pickup" We had some discussion about the mechanics of the binding of objects and how this could work in our settings the game we ended up use these two types of binding because even if these concepts are somewhat artificial, they are very useful to keep a balanced economy game. We also ended up creating a new system, about which we are confident that gamers will really enjoy and they will find appropriate in the Star Wars universe. This is something we are not yet ready to discuss.


Emmanuel Lusinchi also fields questions about how Sith are able to heal and the absence of a Sith soldier class. The post is roughly translated below.

Emmanuel Lusinchi
The Sith inquisitor healing methods that follow a theme really dark and sinister, with skills like "Black Infusion, "Consumption" etc. Despite this, in principle, the game mechanics in care of the Inquisitor is similar to the Jedi Consular, purely for reasons of balance.

Now, about having a class of soldiers on the side of the Empire ... We thought it would be too much duplication with the history of Secret Agent (who is a member of the imperial elite military forces) and too much duplication with the gameplay of the Bounty Hunter (long range, based on technology, combined with damage heavy armor). This is a good idea that we discussed at length at the beginning of the project.


Emmanuel Lusinchi explains his sudden entrance to the official forums. The post is roughly translated below.

Emmanuel Lusinchi
We finally dug up a French-speaking developer? Welcome!

Well, actually I'm from the very beginning of the project (and even a little before ...).

But I have lots of excuses! Like: a lot of work, and ... uh ... lot of work.
Oh, and typing in French on a QWERTY keyboard is not ideal.

Comments

Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2
  • #18 Jaramukhti
    "... and more than one D&D campaign floating around."

    How do I get into a campaign that Daniel Erickson is GMing?
  • #15 EarinShaad
    And with this post, Damion Schubert is now nearly my best-liked developer, very, very close behing Mr. Erickson. Great work, Damion, and thx for taking the time to give us such a funny and intersting insight into your work. :-)
  • #8 abner_ford
    I'm completely fine with the lack of dual-specs. I've always been against it in other games, personally. I don't think that the decisions one makes upon leveling or end-game speccing should be so trivial that you can switch it on a whim.

    I understand some people's desire for convenience, but when does that infringe on the challenge? When does it keep people from having to be creative and adapt on the fly when necessary?
  • #16 Stenmark
    In general, you need different builds for -

    - PvP and PvE - if you do both you need to respec constantly back and forth;
    - PvE raids and PvE flashpoints - "no companion build" or "companion build";
    different builds. If you are perfectionist or pushing your game with companions to the limit, then you need different builds;

    These are quite a lot of options for a game without dual or multi-spec. Each respec requires traveling (time) and additional "grind" to get extra credits.

    It shouldn't be a major problem at launch, but definitely something to do asap after that.
  • #11 DarthShnooky
    Agreed. Plus with the companion system there really isn't the same issue in other MMOs where tanks or healers sometimes have a hard time solo questing. I remember playing WoW at launch as a Warrior, basically had to wait and heal between every fight while questing...a pocket healer companion would have completely changed that experience!
  • #12 abner_ford
    Good point. I leveled as a protection warrior at launch because I was tanking for my friends and... man, that was a dumb idea.
  • #14 DarthShnooky
    Yup, fortunately my gf played a shadow priest so we were fine together...but if i tried to solo it was just painful. Looks like tanks in TOR have enough damage to roll solo though (which is awesome!) and i remember seeing something that said the stat that boosts your healing efficacy also made your pets stronger. Don't know if that has/will change but it seemed like a genius move to me!
  • #13 Socrates
    I tried to level a healer in DAOC solo. There was no spec that could kill as a healer in that game. Would fight a green for 5 minutes and it would just be a stalemate.
  • #6 DarthShnooky
    Curious about the different "Bind on" system hinted at in that post. Perhaps Bind on Account? Or the ability to unbind certain items? Maybe being able to pass on an item from one of your character to another, since Anakin's saber is passed on to Luke? Or the ability to loot a copy of certain items off dead players in PvP? Lots of possibilities and i'm just speculating here.

    I don't really think dual spec is needed in a game at launch. It was needed in WoW because after 3-4 years of the game being out, people had a really strong sense of the ways they wanted to play their classes, with little need for experimentation. Nothing wrong with making it a bit more difficult to jump between specs while playing. Of course, i say this now but 3 months after release i'll be whining for dual spec. :)
  • #4 Teras
    I know some people stayed up for countless hours to bring us this! Thanks!
  • #5 DarthShnooky
    Many Bothans died to bring us this information.
  • #7 JediCosmin
    Beat me to it :P
    You win a Dark Side cookie.
  • #10 DarthShnooky
    Excellent, i shall dip it in my blue milk!
  • #3 Convertible
    Thanks for the post! It was fun and interesting to read. :)
  • #2 Joerazz
    Working there sounds like fun. I've been trying to get a job there to get closer to family for two years now. It's tough. Very rewarding though.


  • To post a comment, please login or register a new account.

Most Commented Articles